This article first appeared on GuruFocus.

Target (NYSE:TGT) shares fell as much as 5% after the retailer recalled a controversial Halloween costume and apologized, injecting fresh brand risk into a turnaround that had finally started gaining traction. The immediate financial impact of one recalled product is likely small, but the bigger investor concern is whether another consumer backlash can disrupt the traffic recovery underpinning Target's recent stock surge.

Warning! GuruFocus has detected 8 Warning Signs with TGT.

Is TGT fairly valued? Test your thesis with our free DCF calculator.

The costume, marketed as the "Kids' Glows Under Blacklight Circus Clown Halloween Costume," drew criticism from consumers who said it resembled racist imagery associated with minstrel shows. Target said the product "never should have been in our assortment" and that the company would "learn from this and do better."

The backlash quickly spread online, including boycott calls, while Target shareholder SOC Investment Group said the episode was "another example ... where Target has lost trust with its consumer base."

That matters because Target competes differently from Walmart (NASDAQ:WMT) and Costco (NASDAQ:COST). Its business depends heavily on discretionary merchandise, brand appeal and the shopping experience, making consumer sentiment especially important. Morningstar analyst Brett Husslein said the stock reaction reflected "the fragility of (Target's) competitive positioning."

The controversy also arrives at an awkward moment. Target shares had gained roughly 70% this year and reached a near two-year high Monday as investors increasingly bought into CEO Michael Fiddelke's turnaround.

Recent operating numbers supported that optimism. Target reported second-quarter comparable sales growth of 3.8%, driven by a 3.6% increase in traffic, while digital comparable sales climbed 8.7%. The retailer also raised its full-year net-sales growth outlook to around 5%.

The key question is whether the backlash remains a short-lived social-media issue or begins showing up in customer behavior. Investors should watch comparable traffic, discretionary-category sales and digital growth over coming quarters, particularly after Target spent the past year cutting prices on more than 10,000 items to rebuild its value proposition. A sustained slowdown in traffic would challenge the turnaround thesis, while continued positive comps would suggest the controversy has limited financial impact. Target's roughly 6% operating-margin outlook is another critical metric, especially because part of its 2026 earnings boost came from tariff refunds rather than underlying operations.