The deserted homes in a once-thriving Indian fishing village stand as a physical reminder of what happens when climate pressures push people inland, uprooting entire communities and disrupting traditional ways of life.
The former residents of Old Podampetta, situated along the country's east coast, have been driven out of their village by increasingly powerful cyclones and shoreline erosion. While many have attempted to build new lives elsewhere, research has found that successful relocation requires much more than just a new home.
According to The Conversation, studies of climate relocation in Bangladesh and India suggest that government programs implementing so-called "managed retreat" often fall short of providing the comprehensive support that effective relocation requires.
The findings are significant considering the massive number of people projected to be displaced due to the changing climate and rising sea levels.
In 2024, sudden climate hazards displaced about 8 million people in India and Bangladesh alone, the publication reported.
Of these millions of displaced evacuees, many do eventually return home. However, others cannot, often because erosion, flooding, and storm damage have left their communities too unsafe to rebuild.
The research indicated that to make permanent relocation a success, individuals must have the opportunity not only to have a new home, but also to recover lost livelihoods, relationships, and a sense of belonging. Without those things, even a move away from physical danger can leave families stuck dealing with other kinds of hardship, such as extreme poverty and a lack of access to necessary resources.
Because of this, managed-retreat policies that prioritize physical safety alone can ultimately end up worsening inequality rather than helping communities build a more secure future.
When approached correctly, relocation can improve life in important ways for some families.
For example, one interviewee living in Bangladesh's Khulna district described the relief of finally having a stable place to live.
"Earlier, we were living as tenants," the person explained, per The Conversation. "We lived in other people's houses. From time to time, we lived in different places. We did not have a settlement in one place. We did not have a fixed house."
Having a formal, permanent address can make it easier to access government benefits, obtain legal recognition, apply for loans, and participate in skills training.
For many transplants, however, escaping climate danger can bring a different set of problems, including isolation, poor infrastructure, and fewer ways to make a living.
Some households that had previously been able to rely on growing their own vegetables and fishing in nearby waters have found themselves forced to pay for food.
"We have to buy everything here," one displaced individual told researchers, per The Conversation. "We never had to buy rice, vegetables, or fish [in the place where we lived before]."
By conducting fieldwork among relocated communities in Bangladesh and India, researchers have begun to better understand the factors that lead to successful climate retreat. Throughout the two countries, they found uneven outcomes: Some relocated households gained better housing or market access, while others lost farmland, forests, fishing grounds, or informal work.
The findings led the researchers to conclude that successful relocation programs require meaningful community input, fair compensation, usable roads, and a plan for earning an income after the move.
Additionally, the researchers concluded that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to climate relocation. The outcome depends on specific details like where people move, what work they can find there, and whether essential services are accessible.
The image of Old Podampetta, the abandoned fishing village, serves as a symbol of the challenges facing relocated communities, as well as a reminder that some of what they have lost can never be regained.
As one study participant told the researchers, "Is there a greater sadness than having to leave the place of your birth?"
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.